Some Criticisms of Berardi

  1. Lacks systematization, his claims might as well lack any warranting to begin with. His book Futurability could be a book of aphorisms and it would have the same level of proofs.
  2. Mixes up consciousness with subjectivity, fails to establish a link (if there is one to begin with).
  3. With recent Scientific research, we have found that there now seems to be a correlation regarding political heritability (political inheritability being about 40%); there are also recent claims as to our lack of “rational” choice (it appears, according to recent studies, that we already act before we even consciously know we are going to act). In Berardi’s work there seems to be inefficient (if at all) dispelling of this — something of which is required for several premises of his to function.
  4. “And the American people are more intolerant than ever, more quick to hate” (36). Is it not possible to say the exact opposite is also happening (given his thinking regarding tendential forces)? Identity politics is on the forefront of “left”-liberal politics, tolerance is at an all-time high. The power relations behind this tolerance having clear racism implicit within it, this being seen in the very question: who gets to tolerate, and who gets to be the tolerated?

--

--

--

The first moment of identity is life, this of which requires self-reflexivity.

Love podcasts or audiobooks? Learn on the go with our new app.

Recommended from Medium

On the Soul

When Psychology and Physics Start Doubting

On Reason

Mental infections

Dual Aspect Monism in the Implicate Order of Bohm and Hiley

Why philosophy is important?

Western vs. Eastern Ideas of Consciousness and Physical Reality

100 % World

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Amar M. Deville

Amar M. Deville

The first moment of identity is life, this of which requires self-reflexivity.

More from Medium

Impotence in Contemporary Politics

Theses on Reason, Faith, and Unknowing

Women’s Liberation

Pictured: A painting of Nana Asma’u. One of the earliest women’s rights scholars in the world.

Contra Naturalism (1)